"intelligent, profound and unsettling....Auds will walk out of their theaters,get in their cars and check on their kids, not necessarily in that order."
- John Anderson, Variety
"A fascinating documentary of the nightmarish story behind an urban myth come true."
- Logan Hill, New York Magazine
"Cropsey can be seen as The Blair Witch Project by way of Zodiac and Capturing the Friedmans."
- Brandon Harris, Filmmaker Magazine